Suburban Light

In lieu of the photos which I didn't take in Southampton, a perambulation with Google streetview, atypically on the good old things rather than the bad new. When growing up in a city, you don't think much about why your environment is how it is. In Southampton, we knew certain things. Mandela Way was hardcore, St Marys was hardcore but interesting, Holyrood estate, home of Craig David, was where those who tried to batter you at the weekend came from, and Highfield and Bassett were posh. As a class traitor, most of my friends were from the latter, and I still recall a certain shock at the size of their houses, these grandiose semis with their vast back gardens, which would become the site for frantic cider drinking when parents were absent - space out of kilter with what seems (and is) a very dense city. Along Highfield Lane are certain developments which look posh, but in a rather different way. One of them, Glebe Court (above), resembles in its planning some kind of costume drama manor house - if you look closely, you realise these are actually terraces, but they aren't real terraces, not Victorian, with no line of cars parked along the shabby kerb. This puzzlement was an inadvertent introduction to the mundane and peculiar world of Garden City architecture.

Of all the things once derived from some kind of socialism, the garden cities are among the most difficult to trace back to their original impulse. They aren't council housing, which has over the last few decades come to signify a kind of housing of last resort; but they were 'affordable' housing, an early example of that euphemism, an ambiguous attempt to either give decent housing to, or make 'property-owning democrats' out of, the lower orders. I suspect Letchworth, Welwyn and Hampstead Garden Suburb, rather than being emergency housing, were mainly inhabited, early on, by that grey area between the reading, unionised working class and the insecure, poor, reading lower middle class. I come from this grey area, and am very defensive of it, particularly because it no longer seems to exist - but the romanticisation of these schemes leads to the fallacy that housing associations are better landlords than the apparently faceless state, and that 'mixed' developments are anything other than an alibi for gentrification. Regardless, the Southampton outpost of the garden cities derives from one such: the Swaythling Housing Society, started by Quaker architect Herbert Collins, who built several developments, mainly of small, leafy terraces, in the north of the City. Architecturally, they initially seem rather dull. Certainly the materials are good, the space unusual and the designs confusingly classless, but the form is neo-Georgian, promising none of the angularity and futuristic scale of the later City architects like The Spence, Lyons Israel Ellis or L Berger. They looked like better, more verdant versions of the nearby neo-Georgian sink estate, the Flower roads (mine, the cream-painted one in the middle, if you're wondering - turn right and then left to get to the Collins stuff)

The North of Southampton is kindly described by the Buildings of England, over-kindly, as suburbia at its best. Walking at night from the Victorian urban of Shirley to well-to-do interwar suburban of Highfield and back is alternately dispiriting and intriguing. A road named after Cunard fails to evoke either the modernity of the ships or the beauty or leftism of Nancy. The Common dominates everything, and I wonder if the strange lack of coherence of this City is partly due to all the parkland in the middle, cutting areas off from each other, flattening the landscape. There's some moderately handsome Victorian B&Bs, but mostly this is the world rendered poetic and elegant (well, someone had to) on The Clientele's Suburban Light. Empty, quasi-rural space, birdsong, trees overhanging dim streetlights, arterial roads lined by semis, whimsical post-war churches with unintentionally funny posters, the distant glow of chip shops and off licences, yellow Neighbourhood Watch signs, the clocktower Dudokery of the King Edward public school, and a bit further on the strangely American, Sunnydale High-ish campus of the FE college which I used to attend, with a yawning green space between you and the city centre - and seldom a soul in sight. It's a place surprisingly easy to become sentimental about, until you remember how when you lived near here, you loathed its privilege and smugness.
I took a wrong turn on this familiar route, and ended up chancing upon one of Herbert Collins' enclaves. Maybe it was the darkness, or maybe the relief of coming across them after the seemingly endless Tudorbethan semis that seem to stretch for miles round here, but suddenly their true modernity, their contrast with the rest of suburbia, became apparent. This is, in its retrogressive, Merrie England way, collective housing. You notice this in the walk from the villas, with their driveways and gigantic hedges, all of which loudly proclaim their lack of sociality, to these terraces, courts and flats. One row of them in particular is a moment where you can really see the link between the garden city and the clean-lined new city of the Weimar Republic, where you remember that Ernst May used to work on Hampstead Garden Suburb. A whitewashed row, with Voysey-like angular chimneys, cohesive and coherent rather than blandly individualistic. Then, walking a bit further on, and working out where I was, they gradually developed into blocks of flats - and outside one of them, a plaque: 'Herbert Collins, Architect and Worker for Peace'. I mention this in the pub to one of my Highfield friends, and she rolls her eyes, evidently having heard a great deal of self-regard about these places, viz a residents newsletter dedicated to complaining about new developments and travellers. I don't doubt they sell for preposterous amounts. There is, though, a faint outline of their social aspirations still just about visible.

Of all the things once derived from some kind of socialism, the garden cities are among the most difficult to trace back to their original impulse. They aren't council housing, which has over the last few decades come to signify a kind of housing of last resort; but they were 'affordable' housing, an early example of that euphemism, an ambiguous attempt to either give decent housing to, or make 'property-owning democrats' out of, the lower orders. I suspect Letchworth, Welwyn and Hampstead Garden Suburb, rather than being emergency housing, were mainly inhabited, early on, by that grey area between the reading, unionised working class and the insecure, poor, reading lower middle class. I come from this grey area, and am very defensive of it, particularly because it no longer seems to exist - but the romanticisation of these schemes leads to the fallacy that housing associations are better landlords than the apparently faceless state, and that 'mixed' developments are anything other than an alibi for gentrification. Regardless, the Southampton outpost of the garden cities derives from one such: the Swaythling Housing Society, started by Quaker architect Herbert Collins, who built several developments, mainly of small, leafy terraces, in the north of the City. Architecturally, they initially seem rather dull. Certainly the materials are good, the space unusual and the designs confusingly classless, but the form is neo-Georgian, promising none of the angularity and futuristic scale of the later City architects like The Spence, Lyons Israel Ellis or L Berger. They looked like better, more verdant versions of the nearby neo-Georgian sink estate, the Flower roads (mine, the cream-painted one in the middle, if you're wondering - turn right and then left to get to the Collins stuff)

The North of Southampton is kindly described by the Buildings of England, over-kindly, as suburbia at its best. Walking at night from the Victorian urban of Shirley to well-to-do interwar suburban of Highfield and back is alternately dispiriting and intriguing. A road named after Cunard fails to evoke either the modernity of the ships or the beauty or leftism of Nancy. The Common dominates everything, and I wonder if the strange lack of coherence of this City is partly due to all the parkland in the middle, cutting areas off from each other, flattening the landscape. There's some moderately handsome Victorian B&Bs, but mostly this is the world rendered poetic and elegant (well, someone had to) on The Clientele's Suburban Light. Empty, quasi-rural space, birdsong, trees overhanging dim streetlights, arterial roads lined by semis, whimsical post-war churches with unintentionally funny posters, the distant glow of chip shops and off licences, yellow Neighbourhood Watch signs, the clocktower Dudokery of the King Edward public school, and a bit further on the strangely American, Sunnydale High-ish campus of the FE college which I used to attend, with a yawning green space between you and the city centre - and seldom a soul in sight. It's a place surprisingly easy to become sentimental about, until you remember how when you lived near here, you loathed its privilege and smugness.
I took a wrong turn on this familiar route, and ended up chancing upon one of Herbert Collins' enclaves. Maybe it was the darkness, or maybe the relief of coming across them after the seemingly endless Tudorbethan semis that seem to stretch for miles round here, but suddenly their true modernity, their contrast with the rest of suburbia, became apparent. This is, in its retrogressive, Merrie England way, collective housing. You notice this in the walk from the villas, with their driveways and gigantic hedges, all of which loudly proclaim their lack of sociality, to these terraces, courts and flats. One row of them in particular is a moment where you can really see the link between the garden city and the clean-lined new city of the Weimar Republic, where you remember that Ernst May used to work on Hampstead Garden Suburb. A whitewashed row, with Voysey-like angular chimneys, cohesive and coherent rather than blandly individualistic. Then, walking a bit further on, and working out where I was, they gradually developed into blocks of flats - and outside one of them, a plaque: 'Herbert Collins, Architect and Worker for Peace'. I mention this in the pub to one of my Highfield friends, and she rolls her eyes, evidently having heard a great deal of self-regard about these places, viz a residents newsletter dedicated to complaining about new developments and travellers. I don't doubt they sell for preposterous amounts. There is, though, a faint outline of their social aspirations still just about visible.
Herbert Collins photos via.

4 Comments:
A belated comment to thank you for posting this nostalgiafest for my personal delectation.
I always found the prissily overmanicured Uplands Estate in Highfield rather scarily devoid of human life - presumably people with real kids got priced out when they became "des res", but the "Olde England" stuff in Bassett is still rather fun.
Hello, i would like to read more about this interesting topic. I think that this post has very useful information.
Really trustworthy blog. sesli Please keep updating with great posts like this one. sesli sohbet I have booked marked your site and am about to email it
Thanks for the information. I really enjoyed, I would like get more
information about this,because is very beautiful, thanks for sharing
kaş ekimde kullanılan ekim tekniği
Post a Comment
<< Home