Constructivism and its Discontents

A point I wanted to make, but didn't have time due to the move (ah, the joys of the Blackwall Tunnel approach!), on Slavoj Z's distinctly shoddy Birkbeck lecture a couple of weeks ago. Though IT has already poked at this, and though I don't intend to join the Parody Centre and Chabert in their increasingly tiresome Zizek-bashing, one moment when he got onto what, with a sort of politico-cultural territorialism I tend to think of as my territory, deserves a proper riposte. In an excursus on the occlusion of Leftist art by Stalinism, he pointed out that the Taylorist, techno-fetishist ideology shared by both Constructivists and Trotskyists was actually more terrifying than Stalinism itself. While this might have created some Zamyatinesque order of instantly responsive biomechanical robots, Stalinism in both its affection for the classics (which I discuss a bit in the most recent comment here) and its preservation of ethics, of a particularly perverse sort, actually saved humanity. Zizek seemed to think this was terribly shocking, and perhaps it is, to the humanist version of Trotskyism, but it is nonetheless utterly ideological.

What it resembles is not only a kind of idiot version of Sartre's claim that the Resistance proved that even under torture one could still make a choice, still be a Man, but at the same time points to the common surrealist/psychoanalytical line on Modernism, akin to Ballard's admission of defeat, 'no-one could fall in love in the Heathrow Hilton'. While the atavistic dictatorships of the 30s or the chaos of capitalism enable some sort of preservation of the bourgeois Subject, and of his majesty the Ego, this could only be destroyed by a society brought into being by a Tatlin or a Corbusier. Essentially this boils down to a hypothetical choice. Between the society dreamt of by Reich, which would have in Brecht's phrase 'effaced the traces' and communalised man out of the Oedipus complex; and a society still brutal, still unequal, which nevertheless preserves Oedipus. It's depressing, but not remotely surprising that Zizek, seemingly like everyone else, would rather choose the latter.

4 Comments:
Essentially this boils down to a hypothetical choice. Between the society dreamt of by Reich, which would have in Brecht's phrase 'effaced the traces' and communalised man out of the Oedipus complex; and a society still brutal, still unequal, which nevertheless preserves Oedipus. It's depressing, but not remotely surprising that Zizek, seemingly like everyone else, would rather choose the latter.
Owen, apart from Zizek, whose bashing can NEVER be as tiresome as his championing by the American and English Left, I see this hypothetical choice as artificial. In Belgrade for example you have the kind of chaotic architecture where Reich's community exists alongside the Oedipus complex without a problem. There's no need to choose, you can have both.
"In Belgrade for example you have the kind of chaotic architecture where Reich's community exists alongside the Oedipus complex without a problem. There's no need to choose, you can have both."
What?
Dejan, once again you've missed the point: Zizek precisely was saying that Stalinised societies, including comparitively liberal ones like Titoism, were a replacement of a 1920s' Constructivist-Reichian-Leftist-Futurist programme, and were ethically preferable and preferred by the proletariat. That was the opposition he was setting up.
It's depressing, but not remotely surprising that Zizek, seemingly like everyone else, would rather choose the latter.
This sounded like you were embracing the hypothetical choice, but choosing rather for the ''Reichian'' solution vs. the ''Oedipal'' one.
You should be more DIRECT when critiquing Z.
Anyway Zizek's maneuver is perfectly explicable when you consider that (his) Slovenia comes from a burgeois-nationalist tradition posing as queer Leninism; Zizek's favorite architecture is Dutch patrician houses, colored like a Hans Christian Andersen book of fairy-tales, but being hippie nevertheless in the same way that modern Dutch hippies are ''socialist''. And this could simultaneously be a description of Ljubljana.
While Serbia (and Bosnia too) being multi-ethnic societies have always enjoyed overlapping architectures as well as ideologies, and the class distinctions were nowhere nearly as severe as in, say, England (so that the burgeoisie and the prole often lived together in Courbisier's complexes e.g. New Belgrade).
That you actually NEED to bring this into view for English-speaking readership only makes me more convinced that the bashing must continue, and intensify, but excuse me now I have to consult with Patrizia di Malizia for the upcoming first hearing at the Parody Tribunal.
Post a Comment
<< Home