Monday, March 12, 2007

Pleasure Districts



"Come friendly bombs and rain on Hoxton..." urges the Impostume. The other day I made a rare foray into the area vaguely defined as the (sharp intake of breath) creative quarter just at the tip of Bishopsgate. A couple of things occured to me. One, the bizarre situation whereby genuine sartorial and tonsorial extravagance, as exhibited by Goths of various kinds is somehow de trop, while Hipsters have a uniform of lank hair, jeans and beards; two, the weird historical place of somewhere like Shoreditch. The whole area between Old Street and Spitalfields has become essentially a huge pleasure complex for the scions of the bourgeoisie, while at the same time still being notably gross, crumbling, full of potholes and staggeringly ugly, despite the absurd amount of money it costs to live there.



Gentrification here no longer seems even interested in prettifying, only replacing WC venality with their own. When before have there been whole districts dedicated to this collective self-indulgence? I mean there's been sundry Haight Ashburys or East Villages, but they had projects, a point, no matter how silly: this meanwhile just seems to be a mass celebration of beery, coked-up nihilism: Vice as the Yellow Book of 21st century fashionable cretinism. A bit depressed by all this, and by the rockabilly guff that had been the original point of this excursion, I had a wander, past some ghastly Barratt flats for said Creatives down to the Boundary Estate, the 1890s redbrick monument to municipal socialism just off Shoreditch High St. In Keiller's London, 'Robinson, in his nostalgia thought of this as a utopia, a fragment of a golden age, and he sat and contemplated it for hours'. As soon as I approached it, someone yelled at me 'NO FAGGOTS IN THIS TOWN, MAN!'

11 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's great to read a post so interesting and so funny. More power to you and your wanderings.

9:16 pm  
Blogger X said...

Two things. First, may I point you to this essay:

http://thelondonparticular.org/items/creativedestruction.html

Second, may I venture that Virilio point that the situation you describe apropos Shoreditch ("The whole area between Old Street and Spitalfields has become essentially a huge pleasure complex for the scions of the bourgeoisie") coheres as well to London (and the Western city) more generally. Furthermore, I would question what you mean by the use of "bourgeois" in this context - you were in Shoreditch on a Friday, I believe - did you really think that it was a *bourgeois* crowd that was moving through the area, drinking to excess, throwing-up, snogging and fighting? Certainly, such praxis bears very little resemblance to the the behaviour of the historical bourgeoisie of the C.19th century, obsessed with decorum as it was...

10:36 pm  
Blogger X said...

"When before have there been whole districts dedicated to this collective self-indulgence?"

Coney Island in the late nineteenth century was perhaps the model. Interestingly, an area was anti-bourgeois to a large extent.

10:39 pm  
Blogger Unknown said...

you really think that it was a *bourgeois* crowd that was moving through the area, drinking to excess, throwing-up, snogging and fighting

You know as well as we all do the inhuman thoughtlessness at the heart of the trust-funded. Call 'em bourgeois, or simply arrogant arseholes, they're definitely not averse to puking and rutting in the place they currently reside...after all, they'll only stay there a few years before buying a place in the Home Counties, procreating and starting the whole damn cycle all over again.

11:48 pm  
Blogger X said...

"You know as well as we all do the inhuman thoughtlessness at the heart of the trust-funded."

But it is too simple to then make the further step, and say that *all* inhuman thoughtlessness can be directly traced back there. I contend that the class composition and affective dynamics of a Shoreditch Friday-night cannot be adequately understood so long as one rests content with simply calling it bourgeois. This is not say, incidentally, then that it is proleterian, but only that there are some affective and ideological complexities at work here that cannot be reduced to this kind of a binary model. Furthermore, I would argue that, if it is true that Shoreditch ever was (and it might well have been) "essentially a huge pleasure complex for the scions of the bourgeoisie," then this kind of thing is passing away - the rising property values Owen is pointing to here relate to the increasing number of city professionals moving into the area, steadily squeezing scions of the bourgeoisie (like me) out.

12:36 am  
Blogger it said...

Move south, then!

9:27 am  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Daniel, interesting points all round. On Coney Island, I suppose I should have clarified how different the Spitalfields-Old St-Hoxton Sq axis is from something like that (UK equivalent would be Blackpool, I guess?) as there you had people with a damn good reason for self-indulgence, i.e the Taylorised working class. Meanwhile there have always been bourgeois pleasure districts but they've never been so obviously gross: the trail of kebabs and coke at the tip of Shoreditch High St...cf your point about whether or not this is really 'bourgeois'. Obviously in the 19th sense it is not. But I don't think lack of decorum signifies the emergence of a new class.

I would also argue that there is an elective affinity (well, more than elective- frequently this is the same people) between churners-out of media tat in Great Eastern St, the administratots of dematerialised capital down Bishopsgate, and the grindewrs-out of proletkult in the Isle of Dogs. It's all the same thing, as far as I can tell, except perhaps that the first of these three seems to have a great deal more leisure time.

6:57 pm  
Blogger X said...

"churners-out of media tat in Great Eastern St, the administratots of dematerialised capital down Bishopsgate, and the grindewrs-out of proletkult in the Isle of Dogs."

Hate to come across like a witless pedant, but could you unpack this one? It does indeed seem as if your three categories all share a certain structural sympathy, but I'm not entirely sure what they refer to.

1:12 am  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Respectively, the first refers to artists, designers, mere pseud mags eds and such; two, square mile city workers; three, the press in canary wharf. Apologies for the many typos...

4:40 pm  
Blogger X said...

Ok

4:49 pm  
Blogger X said...

Sorry - I mean, OK: I think I need to construct a more thorough response here - expect something in a few days...

4:50 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home