Friday, March 09, 2007

New Solemnity vs Neue Sachlichkeit



K-Punk replies to my Kino Fist Brecht piece, and extends instructively the remarks about pop made at the end of the post.

5 Comments:

Blogger X said...

But wait.. Who is arguing for the Neue Sachlichkeit?

10:44 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

me!

4:42 pm  
Blogger X said...

What make you, then, of Benjamin's critique?

10:25 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

(in The Author as Producer, a copy of which I do not have to hand, but which, IIRC, runs along the lines of "The Neue Sachlichkeit simply spectacularized suffering..."

6:12 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

I mean it in the broadest terms, as in John Willett's excellent The New Sobriety, to mean essentially most Weimar culture post-1923, from Mies to Brecht to Piscator: Benjamin was referring quite specifically to the school of painters (the later Dix, Schlichter etc), photographers like Renger-Patzsch, a certain kind of semi-engaged journalism. His main kicking of this is administered in the essay Left-Wing Melancholy btw.

Really, my advocating of a Neue Sachlichkeit is part of a general overarching New Functionalism that I might write a manifesto for sometime...

6:46 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home