A Suburban Occupation
Most people reading this blog will be familiar with the campaign to Save the Philosophy Department of Middlesex University (if not, this is still the best precis). This post is about (some of) the spaces the University occupies, and how the occupation of them by protesting students works with (sub)urban space. The interesting thing about Middlesex is how totally suburban it is, a series of disconnected outposts in several outer north London boroughs, and it's just possible the various actions suggest what can, and possibly can't be done to politicise these places, so far from the purely metropolitan idea of protest as something which happens in highly symbolic central locations (Trafalgar Square, Clerkenwell Green, the Sorbonne, Hyde Park etc etc). I only attended two of these actions, one of which was basically the end of an action, so this should all be considered highly tentative and incomplete (despite slightly inaccurate presence holding up one of these 'I am Spartacus'-style captions).
Middlesex has multiple campuses, spread around north London and elsewhere, with an effect of maximum decentralisation - not only in north London, but far elsewhere - Mauritius and Dubai each have a branch of the University, both of which are no doubt more important than the Philosophy department. The only places that will be mentioned here are in Cockfosters and Hendon. The first occupation took place at Trent Park, the campus where the philosophy department is based, and which I already knew from several public events held here by the Philosophy dept. This is one of those places where the 'green belt' instituted around London in the '30s can be seen to not be entirely fictional; I have an aerial photo somewhere which shows the rows of semis suddenly stopping round here, and rolling countryside taking over. It's served by two of the finest Charles Holden stations, which were advertised at the time as outposts in the country, not the 'burbs - Oakwood and Cockfosters. They're both gloriously non-cost-cutting, extravagant buildings, for all their minimalism. The first thing you notice on the platform at Oakwood, though, is this:
Where a prospective Middlesex postgraduate is literally personified, facialised as a series of demands, alternately hedonistic and utilitarian, and always grimly conformist, headed of course by 'I want to be more employable', it continues thus: 'I want to be the best. I want to do my own thing. I want to excel. I want to go to the gym. I want to study business law. I want to see West End shows. I want business sponsorship.' And with particular bathos: 'I want to see what's possible'. Not a lot, it would seem. The station itself is absolutely vast, a huge, airy cathedral of commuting, and eminently picketable at rush hour. But to get to Trent Park itself, you get a bus from Oakwood, which takes you to a country house alternately used by the Ministry of Defence and Siegfried Sassoon, surrounded by some smaller, ad hoc buildings built either by the University, the Poly or the MOD. For obvious reasons, this is where the students first went into occupation, and for symbolic and strategic purposes as the home of Philosophy itself it's the place to do it; and the photos which have done the rounds showing its clipped classicism bedecked with various banners, with the red & black flag in the centre, had the desired effect. It's especially neat that one of the statues was already giving the socialist salute:
For over a week this was a 'Transversal Space', ie a Free University, with speakers and actions taking place inside the usual University spaces. The thing with Middlesex, and what makes it so unlike occupations at SOAS or LSE, is that this is already the model of the neoliberal university - totally dispersed, totally atomised, with no particular Traditions of Glorious Rebellion. If, as Mark Fisher argues convincingly in Capitalist Realism, the CPE protests in France could easily be presented as conservative attempts to retain privileges, Middlesex is the exact opposite - what happens when an already neoliberalised student body tries to politicise itself. If this particular University is a factory, like the factory it has learnt one of the principal lessons of the 20th century - if you want to avoid conflict, decentralise, get out as far away from the (imagined) centres of power as possible, disappear from public view, and make the question of who actually holds power as opaque as possible. By the time I got to Trent Park the building had been surrounded by security, and the occupiers had been issued with a (fairly legally dubious) writ. At this point they left the building, which some assumed to be an admission of defeat, rather inaccurately. The University then helped the campaign to continue by suspending several lecturers and students for their contribution to the protests - note also the inevitable use of 'health and safety' in their justification for gratuitous thuggery.
The second part of the actions which I actually saw some of was a rally in Hendon, an area which is somewhat less exurban, and where you can actually walk to the campus, from Hendon Central tube. Here, there's a succession of institutional buildings along a winding suburban main road, not far from the M1 and Brent Cross, all in tasteful neo-Georgian - a library, a town hall, and then the University, a combination of aforementioned '20s retro, recent PFI and the following abominations, examples of the delightful things which occur when Universities enter into 'Partnerships' with property developers. The guilty party here is 'Servite Homes', who are just one letter away from accuracy. Halls of Residence continue to be the most consistently awful buildings in the country, viciously banal hutches provided for what the developers assume to be a captive, ill-informed and easily exploited market (cf the Ghost of Nairn). The students are erecting something more interesting in front of it.
One of the posts I linked to above lambasts rallies with Old Left figures, counterposing them to proper insurrectionary radicalism, as if they're mutually exclusive. What was interesting at Hendon is that one served as the pretext for the other - a convenient cover, to an extent, a means of convincing authority that this was a situation they understood and could deal with easily, quickly transposed into one they didn't like one bit. In short, the event consisted of several speakers (Paul Gilroy, Jim Wolfreys, Nina Power et al), who were quickly followed by the instruction to 'take the squares', which entailed us walking and sitting in the grass squares in front of the university, and setting up a Tent Park, aka a 'Camp for Displaced Academics'. The purpose of this seemed pretty opaque, until students started erecting tents on the space - several small ones to sleep in, and one large marquee, which was then draped with political banners, ranging from direct slogans, oblique pronouncements and at one point, some art-historical point-making. The police, meanwhile, maintained an orange plastic fence around the green squares, because apparently without it there would be 'theft' (in which case they're the smallest, lightest anti-theft barriers ever). More likely, they were maintained as a purely psychological attempt to contain the occupation, in a remarkably unconvincing fashion.
The advantage of this is that here is the symbolic heart of the University, the nearest thing it has to a public face - and it's also next to a bus stop and a main road, meaning that a place which tries fairly hard to stay invisible is forced into visibility, and a - fairly old-school, for neophiliacs - picket is set up, so that passing cars can beep their support (as several did), and so that when the Universities and Colleges Union met the day after, they would have a physical reminder of the closure, the suspensions and the occupation - something which almost certainly spurred them into threatening strike action, something highly unlike this particular branch. At the same time, another part of the occupying group went to show solidarity at Trent Park, where the University had moved their trial of the suspended students - this was originally supposed to be in Hendon, but was moved to Cockfosters because it was 'the best most calm place', ie they assumed it was the place least likely to accommodate protest or publicity. But the occupation continues to take on the desperately calm spaces of suburbia.

9 Comments:
You wrote: "The thing with Middlesex, and what makes it so unlike occupations at SOAS or LSE, is that this is already the model of the neoliberal university - totally dispersed, totally atomised, with no particular Traditions of Glorious Rebellion."
That's not entirely true: Middlesex's fine art provision has its roots in its adoption of Hornsey School of Art which saw much political action in the '60s. In my time at Quicksilver Place in the '90s there was at least one major sit-in (protesting cuts in teaching) which lasted more than a week and references to previous, relatively recent, actions in the same place.
You also say "make the question of who actually holds power as opaque as possible". I worked at Trent Park between 2001 and 2005 so things may well have changed, but at that time the vice-chancellor and the executive all had their offices on the first floor of the mansion which would make protesting there the best place to do so.
In agreement with Colin, I'd say that what's been so interesting about the occupation and these protests is the hidden history of political action that it's pulled out of the Middlesex woodwork. What seemed like a very suburban university oriented around practical vocational ends rather than political analysis nonetheless turns out to have quite a radical history.
What's also interesting, though, is why this continuity feels concealed. I'm fairly sure Middlesex has done more protesting in the last 30 years than my alma mater LSE, but nonetheless LSE has this image of being a politically engaged place which Middlesex does not. Something about the social class of their respective students; the fact that LSE student politicos all mellow out a bit on graduation and go on to seats of power?
We were talking about all this at a reading group during the occupation, which was on Walter Benjamin, history and memory. A fine art student at Middlesex commented that her professors - involved in the '68 action - were excited to hear of what was going on in philosophy, yet unwilling to join in themselves. They were somewhat embarrassed, she said, about their youthful radicalism; keen to see its resurgence anew in Philosophy and yet not prepared to re-enact or revist it again themselves.
Colin: well, not entirely true, but I don't think many people applying to Middlesex are thinking of Hornsey Art College when they do so, let alone thinking about '68. Middlesex presents itself, and to a large extent is experienced as, a diffuse, dispersed university with no particular history. But I'm glad it's easy to find and apprehend the vice-chancellor. That doesn't mean that the students themselves can't be very radical, and politicisation at, say, LSE, Goldsmiths or SOAS is tbh less interesting, in that it's expected to a certain degree, that's part of the Unique Selling Point of these places; but there are more universities like Middlesex, and work and wider culture has more in common with it, if you know what I mean.
I suppose the question of why somewhere like Middlesex could be very politicised and active and yet lots of the students not actually know it is to do with that dispersal, the sense that something happening in Hendon can be ignored in Trent Park (and so forth). The occupation seems to me to be trying to get round this, quite successfully so far...
I'm sure applicants don't think of Hornsey at all. All the more so since Quicksilver Place was shut down and fine art provision reduced and assimilated into the Cat Hill campus. I always had a suspicion that nothing was made of Hornsey's admirable heritage due to its political activity. All the same, a tradition existed that, although hidden, acted as a precedent during our sit-in.
Agree regarding the dispersed nature of the university, it was a strange experience both studying and working there in that sense. I'm glad to hear the occupation is going well.
PS Sorry that I managed to miss Jay's comment. Such a shame that the art faculty is unwilling to support their philosophy colleagues.
Do you "guys" not know that a large number of the most radical LSE lecturers decamped to middlesex and ran social sciences coures that educated a whole gemeration of revolutionary activists ?
(I was one of them)
It may be a "factory" now but that has very little to do with its large no of sites
Students are only radical in historical circumstances that provoke them into activity - AND THAT IS NOW (as it was in 67/68)
Get organised, get linked up with campaigns challenging those making the decisions that ruin our lives as well as our studies !!
In revolutionary solidarity
wildsage
The best essential information is this, that you have try to do very well approaching for that homelessness body and their helping hand. I am so inspired about that, after read your this useful written articles and your opinions also which is so attractive for do something for those
Hotels In Bilbao
nike free sales online
nike free run 2 sale
nike free 3.0 sale
nike free 3.0 womens sale
nike free 5.0 sale
womens nike free run 2 sale
nike free run plus 2 black shoes
nike free run plus 2 blue gray shoes
nike free run plus 2 blue gray shoes
This will not work as a matter of fact, that's what I consider.
Post a Comment
<< Home