Thursday, May 13, 2010

Fear is a Man's Best Friend



For those who find enormous, rambling, political/architectural photo-posts on East and Central European capital cities a little indigestible, 1 - tough luck, cos there's another post in the pipeline on Warsaw and another on Berlin, and besides, don't resent a man his distraction from his new aristocratic overlords, and 2 - here's something far more snappy and less heavily illustrated, a Daily Worker piece by me broadly on the subject of Tony Judt's recent, enormously erudite and passionate, if not always entirely convincing pleas for a 'social democracy of fear', trying to link it to hauntology/nostalgia for the future/and so forth. I haven't quite exhausted my thoughts on these articles yet (nor read them as expanded into the book Ill Fares the Land), but they intrigue me - they're a striking mix of the very original and post-89 banal, and although it would be nice if Judt were able to discuss Marxists or Marxisms without resorting to caricature, we ought to take it seriously. There are of course very definite reasons for having rather large suspicions of the idea of a 'social democracy of fear', which are summarised with admirable ire by Jannon at Sit on the Floor. Nonetheless, as an unsentimental statement of current quandaries from a liberal/soft-left perspective it's fairly unrivalled, what Ben Noys describes as the 'Keynesianism as Katechon' position explained with clarity - which makes it all the more important to ascertain exactly what is so unsatisfying about it. More later, perhaps.

9 Comments:

Anonymous Mike Beggs said...

Good stuff. My view of Judt was permanently poisoned by his slander of EP Thompson in his Kolakowski retrospective in the NYRB a few years ago. But I agree this should be taken seriously.

My reservations are mainly around the idea that the postwar experience was created by government following a Keynesian recipe, and we could get back full employment etc. just by getting out that recipe again.

In fact the long boom was a result of a number of factors which can't just be conjured up by the state. To the extent that policy was Keynesian in that period (at least in the UK and Australia), it was usually a 'Keynesianism of restraint' - macroeconomic levers were used to hold back runaway demand growth in the face of wage-inflation and balance-of-payments problems. In many ways the neoliberal state was prefigured by the Keynesian state - the transition of the 1970s crisis involved a slowdown in growth and hence price stability required a permanently worse level of unemployment. The shift in macroeconomic strategy has been greatly exaggerated - it's just that it felt worse from the 1980s on because it was no longer compatible with full employment. From the same source comes the decline in working class organisation.

So the narrative about the rise of neoliberalism as being essentially about the clash of ideas - the rise of Friedman and Hayek and the eclipse of Keynes - needs a rethink.

That said, it seems likely that any left political renewal at this point in time will be dominated by social democratic ideas, with which we need to engage constructively. I wrote a longish piece about all this for a local (Australian) newsletter here: http://scandalum.wordpress.com/2009/09/09/social-democractic-utopianism-and-capitalist-realism/

12:28 am  
Blogger avvakum said...

I'm as skeptical as you, Owen, and Mike about Tony Judt and for many of the same reasons.

That being said, his intervention couldn't come at a better time, especially in the place where it was produced, the US, where I think that the situation is much more degraded, and has been for longer, than in the UK and Australia.

Speaking of Australia, ABC Radio National recently broadcast the recording of Judt's original "social democracy" lecture at NYU. It was a hauntological performance in its own right, what with Judt already then being in such bad shape that he had to speak through a breathing tube:

http://abc.gov.au/rn/bigideas/stories/2010/2886798.htm

12:39 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Thanks for the piece, Mike - amazed you got something that long and detailed into a newspaper.

Judt can be both dismissive and unscrupulous about anyone on the far left - take this recent exchange, where he asserts with no evidence that the post-'68 left were uninterested in eastern Europe, and then when presented with evidence that large sections of it were deeply involved and interested, resorts to either claiming the evidence is unimportant (apparently, nobody ever read the NLR) and ad hominem (anyway, some of the Yugoslav Praxis writers feted in the NLR were subsequently supporters of Milosevic! So can we similarly retrospectively attack anyone who supported Charter 77 or Solidarity because most of them ended up Thatcherites? Etc). All incredibly annoying, and the tip of a very large iceberg.

But these are brilliant essays, and I think partly because of their unflinching attention to exactly how grim the situation is. I especially like the uncompromised defence of welfare - there's no 'yes, but', no surreptitious praise of means testing or clause for the 'deserving poor', etc, which immediately differentiates it from all current Social Democratic politics; and the tinge of moralism actually strengthens the argument there. The problem is partly historical, as Jannon points out - i.e, why did Social Democracy in Weimar Germany and pre-34 Austria collapse? Precisely because of its fearfulness, its tentative political conformism; and also I suppose, a familiar one - agency. Social Democracy didn't happen because of Keynes and the goodness of kindly technocrats, it was a concession offered largely to counter the threat of revolution and/or Stalinist communism after 1945. There's no such threat now (well, outside of Greece, perhaps) and hence the recent 'return of Keynes' actually means stimulus packages for banks, automobile manufacturers and property developers. Maybe the latter is mentioned in the book?

1:06 pm  
Blogger Looser said...

It's not the Daily Worker, it's the Morning Star yr writing for. Of course you know that, but do I detect a trace of embarrassment in appearing between the pages of the true begetters of The British Road to Socialism? Fie on you! Don't be so tardy!
Didn't you know that along with my beloved Steiner Skools, the Morning Star has been given the go-ahead by Michael Go!-V to open their very owen BRS Academy in Dagenham! It's true! Get on board the decommissioned bendy-battle-bus, b4 it's too late!

4:50 pm  
Anonymous Jannon said...

Yeah, I was rather furious when I wrote that, which isn't always wise.

In many ways, I hope that Tony Judt addressing his audience in his way has made it a bit easier for us Americans to get to universal healthcare without the Blitz.

But when Obama signals that he's willing to entertain the notion of lifting constitutional Miranda rights for U.S. citizens:
http://www.racewire.org/archives/2010/05/with_miranda_obama_moves_danderously_to_the_right.html

...well then I really feel that the situation has gotten to the point where the rhetoric of fear and terror must itself be strenously opposed.

If the Left in America has something to protect and conserve, that something includes the judicial legacy of Gideon v. Wainwright, Massiah v. United States, Escobedo v. Illinois, Miranda v. Arizona, Gates v. Collier, and so on.

It's done an utterly terrible job of defending these gains lately.

But well, those courtroom victories don't stand alone: they were backed up by a social movement.

From the days of the Scottsboro Boys in '32 up through the early 1970s, the Civil Rights Movement mobilized masses of people to change the legal and social structure of U.S. society.

That's also part of the legacy of the Left worth preserving.

Agency, as you say.

9:42 pm  
Anonymous Jannon said...

oh, forgot to say thanks for the link!

12:42 am  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

The Morning Star *does* say Incorporating the Daily Worker on its masthead, you know...

Jannon - yes, the lack of emphasis on the far from fearful social movements that were usually behind such legislation is very telling.

12:22 am  
Anonymous Jannon said...

Okay, one more thing: I have to say that I found one of Judt's recent reflections on 1968 disappointing for a similar reason.

His experience of that time may have been one that made the events seem a bit too much like orgiastic nonsense in retrospect, but 1968 in America was grounded in networks built during the Civil Rights Movement, networks that often took explicit inspiration from and had direct contacts to decolonization struggles in Africa. And in France, 1968 relied in part on networks of the New Left that had been formed during the Algerian War. This stuff is well known. Judt even vaguely, somewhat dismissively, acknowledges the fervency of these issues at the time. 1968 was a failed revolution in many many many many many ways, but to see it as merely an abortive attempt by students with no clue, rather than connected to the wave of revolutionary sentiment around decolonization that gradually swept across the world over the span of several decades seems very limited to me, especially since there were many people at time who were explicitly connecting their movements to Vietnam, and Vietnam to decolonization, and decolonization to Civil Rights and anti-racism.

But he's full of chagrin about how he and his leftist friends missed the beat on Prague '68:
"For all our grandstanding theories of history, then, we failed to notice one of its seminal turning points. It was in Prague and Warsaw, in those summer months of 1968, that Marxism ran itself into the ground. ... Had we cared a little more about the fate of ideas we tossed around so glibly, we might have paid greater attention to the actions and opinions of those who had been brought up in their shadow. ... We in the West were a lucky generation. We did not change the world; rather, the world changed obligingly for us. ... We devoted energy to discussing what was wrong with the world and how to change it. We protested the things we didn’t like, and we were right to do so. In our own eyes at least, we were a revolutionary generation. Pity we missed the revolution."

It's pretty clear that the only one he's referring to here is the anti-Communist struggle. So, mostly he seems to have missed a pretty big point of the revolution that actually grabbed him for its purposes. He seems not to think that playing a very small and very tangential part in continuing to undermine and overturn the remnants of direct Western European colonial control of the world counts for much, even though this form of domination lasted for well over a century. That's a pity. It took a lot of work by a lot of people to get from the world system of 1910 to that of 2010, I'm happy to count the students of 1968 on the tally for helping force the world system to rid itself of this particular form of injustice.

Of course the work of unmaking colonialism is far from completed and seems nearly unraveled now, after Neoliberalism, structual adjustment, and Reagan/Thatcher/Clinton/Blair/Bush. The United States is still a very racist society and the Global South is still disgustingly impoverished and exploited. The end of 20th century Communism didn't solve any of that.

7:15 am  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Without being distracted by the non-question of whether 'Marxism' was to blame either for fairly banal Russian imperialism in Prague, or the Polish Stalinists' grotesque, opportunist anti-semitism in 1968...well, Social Democrat in 'massive blindspot where colonialism is concerned' shocker (Richard Seymour's Liberal Defence is very good on this, incidentally). Funny how each 'latter-day Orwell' seems not to have read this essay.

1:01 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home