Sunday, December 14, 2008

Exhuming McCarthy



Now isn't this sordid? For the thoughtcrime of giving a good review to Richard Seymour's book, it first alleges, incorrectly, that I am a member of the Socialist Workers Party, then calls for my sacking from the New Statesman for this apparently heinous offence. Then after I categorically deny being a member on their particularly psychotic comments thread, the delightful David S Toube claims that, as an occasional writer for Socialist Worker's arts pages, I'm an 'SWP activist' so the accusation still stands. Which would also make the many other non-members who have contributed to the paper, from Tony Benn to Mike Davis, 'SWP activists' - news to the former, I'm sure. Note also that this little crowd of would-be McCarthyites (sorry, 'defenders of free speech') are very keen on throwing around the word 'totalitarian' to describe others...

46 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Owen, why are you even trying to argue with these screaming mentalists? If I were you, I'd be off to see my solicitor: a libel case here would be an absolute shoe-in, though it might result in the page in question being taken down, and thus eliminating the wonderful display of how, bat-shit crazy and just plain stupid this bunch of loons is.

Best of luck.

3:51 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Hmm, libel is very tempting...

4:03 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Tempting. But of course you do realise that you would have to argue in court that your reputation had been damaged by the claim you were an SWP member.

Is it the SWP really that bad?

5:27 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Heh, quite.

Thing is, the claim is that I shirked my duty as a reviewer because 'as' SWP I could not have given the book a fair review. And although it now retracts the falsehood that I am a member, it still has the accusation that as an 'SWP activist' (along obviously with Ken Livingstone, Benn, and a long list of other less famous non-members who have written for the paper) I could not have done my job properly. Which I could sue them for, were I so inclined. Anyone know a good solicitor?

5:33 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Morever, it states that you are a direct equivalent of an active member of Hizb ut-Tahrir.

Also, the screaming nutball at http://www.medialenswatch.blogspot.com/ is, despite your denials and his own source's (partial) retraction, maintaining that you are an SWP member. And a 9/11 conspiracy theorist, to boot.

6:13 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Owen -

The "retraction" states quite clearly that

"if he is really not a member of the Socialist Workers Party, then he is not bound by “democratic centralism”. Therefore, he would not have been obliged to support Seymour’s regurgitation of the Socialist Workers’ Party line, and would be free to provide a critical assessment of the book."

That doesn't seem to be an accusation that you cannot do your job properly.

I would advise against suing, unless you wish to make a fool of yourself.

6:43 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It then continues:

"However, ask yourself. How many people do you know who would write for the newspaper of a totalitarian and anti-democratic organisation, without being substantially aligned with its politics?

Do you know any people who write for the British National Party’s newspapers who are not fascists?"

I'm not a lawyer and cannot advise you to sue or not to sue. If, however, I was in your position, I would at least speak to a solicitor regarding the possibility.

7:10 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Which I could sue them for, were I so inclined. Anyone know a good solicitor?"

If you have the time, go for it. These guys were trying to ruin your livelihood. If they're not checked now they may get worse, to you or whoever next falls under their gaze.

I think what's most baffling is the apparent incomprehension on their part that they have done something wrong. Whilst the internet opens up vast space for expression, it unfortunately also provides a platform for the most squalid and blinkered to mobilise and wreak their havoc indefinitely. It allows immense personal damage to be inflicted over the most trivial and inconsequential pedantry.

If you can put a stop to that before they do more damage, you'd be doing the world a service. On the other hand, a protracted legal contest with them could be exhausting, and might result in them stepping up their sordid behaviour. They'll want you to challenge them, because its a way for them to take over your life, and they'll play it out like it was Ragnarok because in their heads their pathetic nitpicking 'political struggle' is the center of the universe and pivot of history.

They're a bunch of ageing Blairite city professionals, their lives hollowing out in tandem with their leader's project, who have nothing left better to do than play a cargo-cult Orwell on the internet between fucking lithuanian escorts and drinking overpriced wine.

7:12 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Also, there's no retraction in the body or the article, which remains up and still states "This could therefore not have been an honest review. The New Statesman has deceived its readership by hiding the fact of Mr Hatherley’s membership of the Socialist Workers’ Party from its readers."

Again, I'm not a lawyer but I'm not convinced you can get around libel laws by telling outrageous and damaging lies, then tacking "(n.b. might not actually be true. but probably is)" on the end.

7:12 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Whilst the internet opens up vast space for expression, it unfortunately also provides a platform for the most squalid and blinkered to mobilise and wreak their havoc indefinitely."

Amen to that -- check out this bunch of mooks whose leader names himself after the bloody dictator and arch-imperialist Lenin, yet still gets a fawning write-up in an organ of the so-called Decent Left:

http://leninology.blogspot.com

Disgraceful.

8:09 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

A 'bloody dictator' - well, maybe if you take the view that Civil Wars should be fought with passive resistance - an interesting, but unusual contention. And 'arch-imperialist'? Also interesting. Remind me exactly of Lenin's imperial incursions? At a stretch (and assuming you actually know anything whatsoever about Russian history, which is foolhardy of me) you might be referring to the incursion into Poland at the end of the Russian Civil War; but any 'imperialist' intent there might have been affected just a tad by the Polish invasion of Russia weeks earlier.

Anyway, I now have a sort-of apology, and a post now so full of qualifications and updates that it makes them look like clueless shrills. Still, it has been very educational, this.

8:18 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ukraine much? Belarus? *Kronstadt* much? You don't seem terribly well-schooled yourself, but it's pretty clear which script you're reading from. As for the "passive resistance" line, I suppose it depends on whether you think what Lenin achieved was worth it. Though you've written for the SW, it does seem hard to credit that you like Trotsky's way of fighting a war which was not just Red vs White.

It seems more likely, though you seem to take the view that "it was all fine till Stalin turned up," that you think what Lenin ought to have achieved, or, perhaps, wanted to achieve, would have made it worth it.

8:35 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

The idea that the incorporation of Ukraine and Belarus into the USSR are comparable to the colonisation of Africa or India is absolute ahistorical guff.

It's not a question of 'it would all have been fine but for that nasty Stalin', nobody outside of the more silly microsects thinks that; the reasons for the degeneration are tied up with isolation, poverty, invasion by practically every country in the surrounding area (and some not - the US and UK, for instance), and as a definite but wildly overstated factor, certain currents (among several) in Bolshevism. The Bolsheviks did some incredibly stupid things - the suppression of Makhno's army and Kronstadt among them. I have no interest in defending either. But to compare them with the subjugation of most of the planet is contemptible and halfwitted.

8:48 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I adore your use of "incorporation" and "degeneration", and above all "stupid", as if it were all a big mistake, but -- anyway -- comparing the colonisation of India with that of Africa is pretty ahistorical in itself. Which is one reason I distrust your claims about the book.

I'm not sure the average Indian's experience in the twentieth century, or even in the 1920s, was that much worse than the average Russian's; it's an argument worth having, one day, perhaps with less emotive language on both sides -- but hang on, it's you who brought up the contemptible comparison!

Who are you calling a halfwit?

9:07 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Are you 'AN ILXOR', anonymous? Just wondering.

9:23 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

you should've kept that last one up, owen

9:38 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

...as a certain Ilxor used to get very narky about my use of certain words in the comments box here, and I detected a little similarity.

On which note: 'degeneration', in that something which I consider was once laudable became something horrible. 'Decline', if you'd rather, though I'm sure you'd manage to find that Spenglerian somehow. 'Incorporation': area previously part of country as subjugated territory becomes part of it again three years later with full rights of secession, which it used in the early '90s without any legal problems. 'Stupid': because those two acts were brutal and gratuitous, and not essential to the Bolshevik project, cf the early elements such as the direct democracy of the Soviets, the welcoming of anarchists like Emma Goldman to the USSR, the erection of statues to Bakunin in central bloody Moscow, Lenin's State and Revolution, etc. In that sense I would indeed say they were mistakes, although not accidents. You, meanwhile, seem to hold to the position that these were all just pretexts so that the Bolsheviks could establish their dictatorship, which is a common but banal liberal position. On the subject of 'boilerplate' merchants.

Comparisons: you, and someone who started an ILX thread, seemed to think that I was amiss in not mentioning the 'imperialism' of (the other) Lenin in my review, in a manner which suggested you thought it was comparable to that of, say, Clive. If you don't think that, then my comparison doesn't stand, but I hope you can see why I made it.

India/Russia: I imagine that depends on the period. In the 20s I suspect there wasn't much to choose between them - in the 1960s I would wager a hell of a lot. Incidentally, my problem with your language is less its emotiveness, and more its tossed-off weasly smugness.

9:42 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

you should've kept that last one up, owen

I know, but I'd rather work out if the commenter is who I think it is...

9:43 pm  
Blogger Anthony Paul Smith said...

The equivocation of the SWP (with whom I disagree on quite a lot, being much closer to the less sexy SP) with the BNP is just fucking stupid. Not even plain stupid. Fucking stupid. People get upset when their doctor is a fascist because they are actively trying to create a less just world. Socialists may sometimes be in the wrong tactically, sure, but they are trying to create a better world.

10:50 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

...being much closer to the less sexy SP

As am I, as it happens. Though I'm sure that the HP massive can claim that my being in sympathy with them means I'm in favour of handing out redundancy notices in taxis, or something.

10:57 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

You should be sacked from the NS for the crime of being a rubbish critic and a sneering writer. But they like these types at the NS.

11:28 pm  
Blogger Alec said...

My thoughts about the original article are laid out at Harry's Place, Owen. Here're mine about your grasp of Soviet history:

Remind me exactly of Lenin's imperial incursions?

My currently reading is Peter Hopkirk's Setting the East Ablaze: Lenin's Dream of an Empire in Asia. I'd recommend you read it.

In January 1918, Kokand in Uzbekistan was sacked by the Bolsheviks, and ten times the number that died at Amritsar in April 1919 were killed. And this was just a small part of the total dead in the region. Previously, Kazakhs were reputed to have outnumbered Uzbeks 2:1. Afterwards, it was a 1:2 ratio.

The idea that the incorporation of Ukraine and Belarus into the USSR are comparable to the colonisation of Africa or India is absolute ahistorical guff.

Approximately four millions were deliberately starved to death in the Holodomor, a.k.a. Ukrainian famine, of the 1930s. The is not a little known event, but has been extracted in gruesome meticulous detail by the likes of Robert Conquest, right down to train carriage rotas.

Nor was it the only intentional famine of the U.S.S.R. of the decade.

You may not be a member of the S.W.P., but your willingness to overlook millions of dead Slavs and Central Asians is lamentable.

1:44 am  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

I shouldn't bother with this, really, but:

First of all, the (horrible, but no more so than the English, American or Spanish Civil War) conduct of the Russian Civil War and the peacetime Ukranian famine of the early 1930s are obviously incredibly different phenomena to anyone without a very particular agenda.

I have read Conquest, incidentally, and I'd be impressed if you can find any moment where I've ever downplayed, denied or in any way excused the famine of the early '30s. You might, as an apparent reader in Soviet history, note the approach of Lenin's government to the famine that followed the Civil War, where help was publicly sought - and received - from anyone who could offer it, including governments like the US' which had previously had troops involved in said Civil War; and the famine of the early '30s, which was denied, hushed up and where no aid was given to the victims. To claim that I 'overlook millions of dead Slavs and Central Asians' is hyperbolic bullshit of the sort that I've come to expect from the sort of self-righteous prigs who seem entirely content to overlook hundreds of thousands of dead Iraqis.

Now, I'm losing my patience with you lot - I don't operate HP's oh-so-admirable no deletion policy, and more abuse, sophistry or flinging of hysterical accusations and you'll be snipped.

2:05 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

For the thoughtcrime of giving a good review to Richard Seymour's book, it first alleges, incorrectly, that I am a member of the Socialist Workers Party, then calls for my sacking from the New Statesman for this apparently heinous offence.

I hope you don't regard it as "sophistry" for me to ask you to point out where exactly David T called for your sacking? I've re-read the post and it calls on Jason Cowley to reveal your SWP allegiance (and as it turns out, non-allegiance) to the NS readership. Nowhere does he call for your sacking or so much as imply you ought to be sacked. He even mentions that he supports Aslam's unfair dismissal claim against the Guardian assuming editors were aware of his Hizb ut Tahrir membership when he joined that newspaper.

DT got something wrong and immediately updated the post when this was pointed out. (Note, he has updated the post itself and not simply added a footnote as someone has suggested above). Are you going to do the same?

10:39 am  
Blogger Alec said...

Yes, Owen, that would augment your reputation as a steely defender of journalistic integrity and ability to respond to personal criticism. Unlike Richard Seymour (whom I refuse to call Lenin), you're a decent writer with a good turn of phrase, but you're also at the stage in your life when you can write a dozen contradictory things before breakfast and believe every one of them.

I don't intend to go back over my argument at Harry's Place. Suffice to say, I agree Toube was both factually wrong and wrong in principle, and said so. Nor did I engage in the silly inferiority class complex that others did. However, this sort of thing happens on the Internet, and yourself were engaged previously in it with your original article. You were not targeted as a private individual, and to sue would be to be like boxer who calls the Police whenever a punch is landed.

First of all, the (horrible, but no more so than the English, American or Spanish Civil War)

My next-currently reading will be Tristan Hunt's English Civil War I recently read Anthony Beevor's Spanish Civil War! The English Civil War three centuries whence, and the American Civil War war, by and large, between conventionally armed militaries. The contemporaneous Spanish Civil War was horrendous and, in many cases, unprincipled, but unless you're accusing me of Nationalist-sympathies, I fail to see your point.

conduct of the Russian Civil War and the peacetime Ukranian famine of the early 1930s are obviously incredibly different phenomena to anyone without a very particular agenda.

Pardon?

I have read Conquest, incidentally, and I'd be impressed if you can find any moment where I've ever downplayed, denied or in any way excused the famine of the early '30s.

Right in this thread. You didn't say it was as bad as colonization of Africa and India, you said it was not remotely comparable.

sort of self-righteous prigs who seem entirely content to overlook hundreds of thousands of dead Iraqis.

I opposed the Iraq war, and still think it was a grave moral and strategical mistake.

11:04 am  
Blogger Alec said...

Beevor's Battle for Spain.

11:05 am  
Blogger Alec said...

conduct of the Russian Civil War and the peacetime Ukranian famine of the early 1930s are obviously incredibly different phenomena to anyone without a very particular agenda.

Oh, I get it. You're asserting that the Bolsheviks' conduct in the Civil War was conventional war whilst the Holodomor was an act of pure malice.

Kokand was sacked because the inhabitants thought the Revolution was to give them self-determination, whilst Lenin had imperialist ambitions. The Kirghiz rose up because already their lifestock and crops were being requisitioned without regard to their need to feed their families. The Bolsheviks' conduct from the October Revolution onwards was to seize control against the wishes of the majority.

11:23 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

...but you're also at the stage in your life when you can write a dozen contradictory things before breakfast and believe every one of them.

More like you're at that stage in your life where random internet bystanders feel they have the right to patronise you immensely.

(Personally I'd find yourself a good lawyer, and have a little chat with them about it all.)

11:57 am  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Right in this thread. You didn't say it was as bad as colonization of Africa and India, you said it was not remotely comparable.

No I didn't. I was talking about 'Lenin's imperialism', brought up by another poster. Lenin died in 1924, the famine to which we refer was in the early '30s. I have no interest whatsoever in defending Stalinism.

I opposed the Iraq war, and still think it was a grave moral and strategical mistake.

Glad to hear it.

12:31 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Nowhere does he call for your sacking or so much as imply you ought to be sacked. He even mentions that he supports Aslam's unfair dismissal claim

The statement that I was 'the NS' Dilpazier Aslam' had a pretty fucking overt implication, one spotted by almost everyone who read it. I see no evidence whatsoever that Toube 'supports' Aslam's claim - the original post doesn't suggest so - other than as a means of covering his tracks. If Cowley had been subject to the proposed letter writing campaign from you lot, what do you think would actually have ensued? My swift disappearance from the NS, more than likely, as a conflict of interest is a sackable offence (as a freelancer the upshot would have been stopping of commissions rather than firing from a day job, but the point still stands). As it is the post is now so full of qualifications that it looks utterly ridiculous, as it should; though the original untruths are still up there for all to see, as is the implication that as a non-member but an 'SWP activist' (whatever the fuck that means - I've never sold a paper, never canvassed, never done any actual 'activity') the points all stand anyway.

I am however absolutely amazed that you now think that I ought to be showing contrition. A little perspective would be nice.

1:07 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Snip!

2:06 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Jesus, the lice really have come crawling out of the woodwork, haven't they?

Incidently, I note Kamm has repeated Toube's claims on his Times blog, along with an even more ungracious, mean-spirited non-withdrawal, effectively stating that the fact that you're not a member of the SWP doesn't make any difference and that the initial point still stands.

This is all seeming increasingly sinister.

3:28 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Pointing this out has prompted Owen to delete my comments, and has elicited a response from Murphy of "cretin" and from you a suggestion I am a louse."

Being a pathetic prick has prompted Owen to delete your comments. Your playing of silly buggers and fucking around with semantics is more inept, grating and ultimately meaningless than that of a averagely intelligent ten year old. You've demonstrated aptly, both here and on Toube's disgusting smear-machine, your inability (or refusal) to understand anything any argument more nuanced than "Swappies out! Swappies out!". Since base insults seem to be the only thing that register, they're the only thing you deserve.

5:07 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Seriously, why don't you take this stuff to Speak You're Branes? It would be much better appreciated there.

And since we're playing semantics, I said understand, not make. I've never had the dubious joy of having read anything you've ever written on any any other topic than the one at hand, but seriously, if your reasoning extends beyond "Owen is tangentially associated with the SWP and therefore is fair game", I've yet to see any evidence of it.

Answer me straight: is it reasonable to accuse someone of being the direct equivalent of a member of Hizb ut-Tarir on a false premise? Is it reasonable to accuse someone of failing to properly perform a job that they are being paid to do on the basis of an unchecked assumption that even the most cursory examination would have proved false? Is it reasonable to accuse the NS of misleading their readership, on the the basis of the same false assumption? Is it then acceptable to refuse to apologise, to leave the article in place and to tack on a rider to the effect that even though the intital assumption was false, the point still stands because the journalist is vaguely associated with a political party the commentator doesn't like? Do you regard that as acceptable application of journalistic ethics? Or an acceptable means of debate? A effective way of establishing the truth? Or of just basic fucking decency in your treatment of other human beings?

Seriously, why don't you take this stuff to Speak You're Branes? It's would be much better appreciated.

And Mike: I called *you* a loon because you keep talking abour Media Lens when no one else is and where there's no call for it in the context, because you accused Tony Benn, Ken Livingstone and Mike Davis of being "crypto-Swappies", because you chided me for my abusive tone whilst throwing around "stupid", "idiot", "disgusting", "cunt" and "cuntface" all over the discussion, and, because by the end, you were clearing trying very hard not to accuse me of being Richard Seymour. Even Alec MacPhearson, about the only reasonble voice amongst the Harry-ites, accused you of "sounding like the Walter Matthau character in Fail-Safe".

I accused others of being nutters because they were refusing to understand what I had written in plain English, continued to ask me questions I had already answered, and continued to attack straw-men of my arguments after I had pointed out five or six times that those were not my arguments at all.

I like your hat, by the way. It's very shiny. Metallic, actually.

5:41 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"I'm sorry, Colin, in a free society it is perfectly legitimate to discuss people's views and associations. You'll get the hang of it, kid."

Oh, and thanks for illustrating my second to last paragraph above. That wasn't my point of contention. I've made that clear, and made clear what my objection is, probably ten times now. I don't know if you can't read, won't read, or lack the basic skills to draw meaning from the combination of semantics and syntax that construct language. Either way, it's clear that I'd get more sense of the Kindergarden (sic) kids one of your fellow-travellers accused me of writing for.

5:47 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Sorry that your comments won't make sense after I do, Colin, but I'm deleting these pernicious little fucks.

5:55 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"I see no evidence whatsoever that Toube 'supports' Aslam's claim - the original post doesn't suggest so"

Here is the relevant section from the original post -

"I have been told that, although the Comments Editor was unaware of Mr Aslam’s extremist politics, another senior journalist with an interest in Islamism was fully aware - and rather thrilled - about having a real live jihadist on the Guardian staff. If that it true, the Guardian was quite right to compensate Mr Aslam."

Hope this helps.

6:10 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

That infers nothing more than that Toube thinks that Aslam rightfully won his case against the Guardian; but that he should not have been allowed to write for the Guardian in the first place is a blindingly obvious implication.

Next!

6:12 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Sorry that your comments won't make sense after I do, Colin, but I'm deleting these pernicious little fucks."

That's fine, Owen.

I am aware, incidently, of the irony of my first post in the context of my subsequent ones.

6:16 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Right, wankers - I'm leaving the computer for the rest of the evening, write whatever shit you like; all will be deleted when I get home at around 12, so enjoy your moment while you can.

6:34 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Owen for what it's worth I am a regular reader and although I am a Euston Manifesto supporter I, unlike the clowns on the other thread and some on this one, can appreciate writers who do not share my views but have talent. For instance I can't agree with you views on Lenin but I don't see this as any reason for slander and petty name-calling.

I continue to find your blogs and journalism interesting and entertaining, even when I disagree with you. It's a shame others can't offer criticism beyond 'you're a Trot, neeeerrr!!'.

4:19 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oh Christ, this is far too incestuous.

I remember David Toube as a first year law undergraduate in the University of Southampton's Debating Society in 1987/88?

"Very bright, but distinctly lacking in political nous" was my opinion at the time IIRC.

9:55 pm  
Anonymous generic viagra said...

It was a great socialist! I just can't ignore his politics and I think we need more idealist like him in this modernity. By the way, this'll be my nicest blog at the list of bookmarks.

5:27 pm  
Blogger Ashok said...

Nothing against the article, but I disagree with a couple of points to some extenct. I’m probably a minority though, lol. Thanks for sharing.
Barcelona Hotels

4:51 am  
Anonymous ideas de negocio said...

Really trustworthy blog. sesli Please keep updating with great posts like this one. sesli sohbet I have booked marked your site and am about to email it

5:56 pm  
Blogger Unknown said...

Good Article, jual souvenir perkawinan murah di jakarta. thanks for your article. :)

12:15 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home