Tuesday, May 08, 2007

In Praise of the Dialectic



I've been tempted to write a post on Dialectics - spurred on somewhat by the K-Punk-Shaviro-Miller contretemps over Zizek, as a defense of the method against variously Deleuzian affirmationism, 'nihilation' and Slavoj Z's increasing tendency to merely use it as a kind of flip diamat alibi for lazy contrarianism - perhaps relating it to the game attempt of the teacher in the film Half Nelson to teach a sort of version of Brecht's Hegel-via-Lao tzu dialectic, and how above all the value of dialectics as a theory of change. I don't think I will though, mainly because this really quite tremendous post from a distinctly on form Antigram on Madchen in Uniform and Half Nelson does this and a great deal more besides.

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Go on Owen. I for one would like to see your rehabilitation of the dialectic. As it is a continuing debate concerning 300 and Zizek seems to have sidetracked things. Also, they may listen to you.
Off to the 'innocent fun' of reading RE Howard's Conan.
Ben (Noys)

12:18 pm  
Blogger owen hatherley said...

Hmm...I might work something up eventually: although I warn you, it will involve quoting Lenin.

2:39 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Oh dear, no Mao then? I'll just have to try write my own (non)-dialectical theory of negativity sans Lenin plus Bataille. Still I'd be interested in the relation of said dialectics to the party-form today, being an "infantile leftist" and proud of it.
Ben

9:48 am  

Post a Comment

<< Home